Flash chrome or copper-nickel-chrome? Apparently, the metal finish determines the shine from flash chrome. Will your chrome guy do the job if it isn't up to their standards?I agree with MARK the one on the right looks "most" correct.
I have a disassembled trim ring -I unbent the lip and removed the metal ring and clips -
I was planning on using approx 4 different grits on it - 1/4 of the ring in 180grit ~ 1/4 - 220 ~ 1/4 - 320 ~ 1/4 - 400 then having it plated with the next batch of stuff I send for chrome.